The Case of the Constant Suicides by John Dickson Carr

The Case of the Constant Suicides
John Dickson Carr
Originally Published 1941
Dr. Gideon Fell #13
Preceded by The Man Who Could Not Shudder
Followed by Death Turns the Tables

I am never entirely sure how best to approach dipping into the works of a classic author. I can certainly see the appeal of selecting their most famous or successful books at first but then what do you have waiting for you once you’re done?

After starting out with the wonderful The Problem of the Green Capsule, my next few experiences of Carr’s work were of books generally reckoned to be second or third tier works. Some, such as The Problem of the Wire Cage, exceeded expectations while The Witch of the Low Tide felt messy and left me disappointed and underwhelmed. It was time to go to a safer choice…

I am pleased to say that The Case of the Constant Suicides is the best work I have read so far from Carr. It manages to balance its humorous and mysterious elements perfectly to create a book that is as entertaining as it is perplexing.

The story begins with members of the Campbell family being summoned to Scotland following the death of Angus Campbell who seems to have jumped out of a window at the top of a tower and fallen to his death. It turns out that he has very little wealth to speak of but did take out several heavy life insurance policies whose combined payouts ought to add up to a very healthy sum for the inheritors.

The problem is that if Angus did commit suicide those contracts would be voided and the estate would be worthless. The family want to believe that he wouldn’t have committed suicide, knowing the financial pressures it would create for the family, but the alternative of murder seems inconceivable – the tower being too tall and the room being thoroughly locked – so what caused Angus to take the plunge?

It’s a cracking good start for a story and Carr does a superb job of constructing the rules of the locked room, stating the facts clearly. Since starting this blog I have learned that the concept of a mysterious string of identical historical deaths will always grab me and here is no exception.

I knew from early on that this was the book for me when we first see Alan and Kathryn encounter each other on the train. Carr gives the two characters a delightfully entertaining backstory and seems to relish throwing them together. They bicker and spar, make pointed comments and soon it becomes all too clear that they are attracted to each other.

It should be pointed out that these two characters, while related to most of the different suspects, are external characters. This is different from the approach Carr takes, for instance, with Brenda and Hugh in Wire Cage, where they become involved in the case and so need to present evidence and track down the real killer. Some may feel that this subplot is then tacked on, contributing little material evidence, and yet I found it immensely enjoyable and I think it works brilliantly as a device for the family to come together and to share pertinent information with our heroes.

The bulk of the sleuthing however is carried out by our old chum, Gideon Fell. As usual, he manages to see right through some of the noise of the case to find its key points. I think what interests me most about the character is how amoral he is shown to be. There is a moment where he tells the family that, should he find it was suicide, he will sit on the story and find a way to persuade the insurance companies.

Another aspect of the novel that I think bears closer scrutiny is Carr’s decision to write in dialect for his English readers. Should you have read my review of Lament for a Maker another Scottish mystery set in an old castle, you will be aware of just how much I can dislike authors doing this. Carr escapes that trap because it’s only used in short bursts and typically the meanings are easy to infer from their context.

Some may grumble at all the ‘we’re in Scotland’ tropes happening here but I found them to generally be quite charming and amusing. The jokes aren’t mean-spirited in tone which I do think helps keep things light and they are not so frequent that you can’t ignore them.

Towards the end of the novel Carr stacks several other murders on top of the first death, a move which I have found to be the undoing of some of his other works. I am happy to say though that this was something of an exception with one of the secondary crimes more interesting to me than the main case in terms of how it was executed. When the explanations are given for each death, I was suitably impressed by the ingenuity on display and on the way the remainder of the story holds up.

Overall, I was extremely impressed with this Carr read and I look forward to spending more time with Dr. Fell in some of his further adventures. Hopefully it won’t take me quite so long before I come across another top-notch read. As always, I’d be grateful for suggestions shared (I may not have reviewed them but I have experienced The Hollow Man and Til Death Do Us Part).

Vintage Mysteries Challenge: An academic (who)

15 thoughts on “The Case of the Constant Suicides by John Dickson Carr

  1. I am delighted you enjoyed this as much as you did; it was, I think, only the second Carr novel I read, and enough on its own to convince me that the man was a genius and i should track down everything he ever wrote (but then I also love Death Watch, so my reactions aren’t always to be trusted…).

    I hadn’t considered the “outsideness” of Alan and Kathryn, but it does make for an interesting counter-point when you consider the other Fell cases from around this time (Crooked Hinge, To Wake the Dead, Could Not Shudder, Green Capsule, etc) wherein the central couple are also suspects to some degree. I always wondered what it was about this that set the framing apart slightly in my mind, and I think you may have unlocked that particular mystery for me. Many thanks!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Wonderful! I am happy that my thoughts were of use with regards Alan and Kathryn. I have to say it was something of a relief to dispense with the notion that the young lovers might be guilty. There may be some Carr novel I have yet to read where one of them actually did it, in which case I will regret saying this, but it was nice to be able to treat them as just highly entertaining young people.


    1. It is certainly the funniest of his books I have read so far and I was surprised at how many times I chortled or laughed out loud while reading. A lot of that has to do with the Kathryn and Alan relationship – I am a sucker for bickering romance.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Wonderful! This has certainly been a highlight of my experiences with Carr so far. I wouldn’t mind rereading it myself but I may wait a few years. 😀


  2. I read this just 1.5 years ago and your review brought back some nice details that had already slipped from my mind. I’ll always remember this book for the comedy/romance, which sounds like a funny thing for me to say. That scene on the train in the very beginning is just hilarious.

    Don’t worry one bit about burning through all of the good Carr novels too quickly. There are about 10 that fall into the “classic” category, and another 20 that I think most readers would agree are extremely good (he wrote around 70 books overall). From the sound of it, you’ve read four consensus classics. While I enjoy the rest of the books that you’ve read (Wire Cage in particular), by popular consensus I don’t think any of them would fall within Carr’s most favored 30 books.

    If you’re looking to explore some really good books without draining the classics, here are some recommendations:
    -The Emperor’s Snuff Box
    -Hag’s Nook
    -The Red Widow Murders
    -The Four False Weapons
    -The Plague Court Murders
    -Death Watch

    I do recommend that you read the classic The Burning Court as soon as humanly possible. There is an aspect of the book that people can’t help but spoil when they discuss it, so read it now before it’s spoiled for you.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I am with you about just how much the romance stands out here. The train scene had me in stitches (along with people’s assumptions about what they had overheard) but so did each of the hangovers.

      I will be a little bolder in my Carrian selections knowing I have a few classics left to get to. I appreciate the suggestions and will use them as I plan out my next few reads.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. So happy you enjoyed, its an absolute beauty of a story. And glad you have so much more Carr to come! As Ben said, there is so much to choose from, and the ones that are seen as the atone cold classic really represent in one a certain type of Carr book. The others tend to be much more experimental and all the more exciting for that fact.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That is a good way to look at some of those other books. I am very comfortable atm with the Dr. Fell stories but I would like to sample his work a little more broadly.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s