Originally Published 1949
Joe Wilmot can’t stand his wife Elizabeth. But he sure loves her movie theater. It’s a modest establishment in a beat-down town–but Joe has the run of the place, and inside its walls, he’s king. Without the theater, he’d be sunk. Without his leadership, the theater would close in a heartbeat. If it isn’t the life Joe imagined for himself, at the very least, it’s livable.
Everything changes when Joe falls for the housemaid Carol, and the two can’t keep it a secret from Elizabeth. Elizabeth won’t leave Joe the theater unless he provides for her…but he’s put all his money into the show house.
Carol and Joe’s only hope is the life insurance policies they’ve taken out on each other. If one of them were to be presumed dead, they’d have more than enough money to solve all their problems…
When Joe Wilmot is found by his wife Elizabeth in the arms of Carol, their housemaid, she makes him a proposition. She will skip town and leave them together on the condition that she be declared dead and given the insurance payout to allow her to start a new life somewhere else.
Of course, to get an insurance payout you need a body but Elizabeth has a plan for that too. Carol is tasked with finding an unattached woman of a similar physique and luring her to their home. Once there she would be killed in a fire, burning the body to the point where it could not be fully identified.
It is a solid, if ghoulish, plan and the novel begins with Joe taking the first steps in executing it, placing an ad in the local paper to try and find a suitable victim. The chapters that follow not only detail how they are putting their plan into action but also the events that led them to that point, exploring their psychological states at key moments.
One issue that Thompson faces is convincing us that these characters would conceive and develop this plan and I felt that this was the least successful aspect of the novel. Certainly the situation he has devised is interesting, dramatic and quite original but given the nature of what they are planning, I found it challenging to get my head around each of their motivations.
The easiest character to understand is Joe. He had started working for Elizabeth at her movie house but when they married he took over the concern, finding ways to trim costs and work the distributors system to ensure that he was showing the movies he wanted. He loves the business and is deeply invested in it, so it makes sense that he would be willing to consider a plan that allows him to keep hold of it and allow him a fresh start with Carol.
I found it harder to understand the motivations of the two women in his life. In one respect this is appropriate – Joe’s confusion about Elizabeth’s reasons for offering this deal is an important plot point – and I do think Thompson ultimately addresses some of these questions but I found that they lingered over the early part of the novel. My feeling is both women feel underwritten and are given much less definition than Joe.
While the plan wasn’t of Joe’s devising and he is not directly involved in its execution, Thompson’s decision to have him narrate the story rather than using a third person narrative style makes a lot of sense. For one thing, Thompson is able to use his narration to establish aspects of his character but it also allows us to experience his lack of understanding of the thoughts and mentalities of the two women in his life. This leads to some of the book’s richest pages towards its end as Joe reflects on how his marriage to Elizabeth ended up going so badly.
The plan Elizabeth has hatched is quite clever and I think it is credible to think that it might work. The mechanics and characters’ movements are clear and easy to follow while at first glance the murderers are leaving no loose ends. Of course, things will go wrong – that’s just a part of the noir style – but it’s reasonable to think that they might succeed.
The problem of course lies with the insurance company who send an investigator to the town to look into the death. Here, once again, the decision to tell the story from Joe’s perspective pays off as it means that we have little idea exactly what he has found or how close he is to finding out their secret beyond what the investigator tells Joe.
Thompson sets his pieces in place effectively, creating obvious points of tension between the various characters. The reader waits for those tensions to be triggered and to see just how things will collapse and, of course, if anyone will get away with it all.
I also found that I really enjoyed Thompson’s explanations of the movie distribution system and some of the practicalities of running a movie theatre. In these passages Thompson manages to convey some pretty complicated ideas quite effectively, throwing light on how the industry worked in that time.
The supporting characters are similarly quite interesting and I enjoyed following along as things start to go wrong with the plan. Several of these characters are particularly colorful. Some of these issues are quite strongly clued but some others may take readers by surprise.
Though it is not perfect, I found that I liked and enjoyed Nothing More Than Murder. The writing is sharp and the way this story is resolved feels really quite clever.
8 thoughts on “Nothing More Than Murder by Jim Thompson”
A thoroughly enjoyable review — many thanks. Reading it prompted me to go look at the notes I made on this novel back in May 2015 to remind myself what I’d thought back then. It’s quite uncanny how many similarities there are between the two reviews! Clearly great minds think alike.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks. We do seem to be in accord on this one. I had a really good time with this one and plan on further explorations of Thompson’s work over the next few months.
I’m a Thompson fan, as I’ve said before, and have definitely read this one…but remember not a jot about it, as the details remain frustratingly just out of reach — the movie distribution stuff, the essential plan…it’s all in my head somewhere, along with almost every other word Thompson wrote, but it’s eluding me at present. Which is annoying, as I rarely get to discuss Thompson with anyone,/i>. Gaaah!!
However, I’m delighte you enjoyed this, and that you see the cleverness in the scheme; Thompson didn’t get enough credit for the intelligence behind his plots (they’re almost puzzle plots in their complications and precision). Now you’ve got me itching to dig out a Thompson and reread it, but, man, my TBR at the moment is problematic 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
I can relate to that feeling! I was very happy with this one, particularly as it isn’t one of those titles that everyone talks about (or perhaps more accurately that someone talks about). It is a really interesting murder story and I think it pays off nicely. Now to figure out my next one!
I’d advise getting to After Dark, My Sweet before too long…
LikeLiked by 1 person
I checked and I have a copy of that so I’ll make a note to prioritize that one. Thanks!
Jim Thompson is a good writer and enjoyable, but nothing exceptional. Would you believe it, some crazy blogger (I don’t remember who) regard him as one of the kings of crime ! 🙂