I first began compiling this list in response to Curtis’ Friday Fright Night meme (more on that here). You see, being of a somewhat squeamish disposition I don’t typically read books that really fit with the trappings of the horror genre and so I thought rather laterally about things that scare me.
The first thing that came to mind was the idea of losing my memory or my sense of awareness of my own actions. The odd thing is that I cannot really identify the origin of that fear. There is no great incident in my own life I can think of, nor do I have any reason to think that it is likely to happen to me. Still, the idea unsettles me and so I often find myself drawn to stories that use it in some fashion.
One work that does this well, though I have not included on my list, is the fascinating short story Diary of a Serial Killer by Young-Ha Kim. I decided against this book because only one of the stories, the titular one, is really a genre work. That story however is fascinating as we experience the thoughts of a serial killer who is suffering from dementia and struggles to keep his memories and thoughts in order – a dangerous prospect for someone whose life is comprised of secrets that might someday slip out. The presentation of what that would be like and, particularly, how distressing it could be is really effective and makes for a really powerful reading experience.
Looking at the five titles I have picked, none of them are really horrific or spooky in their presentation though I think some create horrific situations for their protagonists. I will try harder next time!
What I tried to do was select five books that handle the idea of memory in different ways, each focusing on some different aspect of it. In some you experience, quite directly, the narrator’s sense of confusion about their actions as they try to piece together what happened. In others the reader is kept at a distance from that character whose memory loss might be treated more ambiguously.
As always with these Five to Try-style posts, I invite you to share your own favorites of stories that play with memory-loss or manipulation in the comments. I love reading your thoughts and expanding on my wishlist of titles to read in the future!
One final note – I might very well have selected Great Black Kanba for this list had I not previously chosen it as part of my Railway Mysteries list just a few weeks ago. That offers a great example of how a character’s memory loss leaves her utterly confused about just who to trust and is definitely worthy of a closer look if you can track down an affordable copy. And so with that out of the way, on with the list!
Ordeal by Innocence (1958) by Agatha Christie
If Only I Had Remembered…
I think it is fitting to begin this list with a book by Agatha Christie since she herself was supposed to have experienced one of the more mysterious cases of amnesia herself. For more on that story, check out this episode of the excellent Shedunnit podcast.
Ordeal by Innocence begins with Arthur arriving at the home of the Argyle family to share some information with them. Several years earlier the matriarch of the family had been murdered and her adopted son, Jacko, had been sent to prison for the crime. He had claimed that he had been given a lift by a stranger at the time but that stranger could never be found. Arthur reveals he had been that man and the reason he could not verify the information was that he had lost his memory due to a car accident.
Unfortunately this piece of newly remembered information does not bring the peace Arthur had hoped for. Jacko had died in prison some time before and, as everyone soon realizes, if it wasn’t him then someone else in the house must have been responsible.
While the premise to this one is rather convoluted, it explores some interesting issues and family dynamics. Christie uses a structure where the story is told from the perspectives of each of her characters which allows us to understand how they are feeling and explore the sense of paranoia that Arthur’s revelation causes in most of them. Though not wholly successful, the book was one of Christie’s favorites and feels quite different from much of the author’s other work.
The Executioner Weeps (1957) by Frédéric Dard (Translated by David Coward)
Who Is She?
Most of the examples I have chosen on this list feature a protagonist who is struggling to piece together their memory of some events that happened to them. This work by Dard takes a different approach by having the person trying to piece that memory together be someone who finds the woman experiencing memory loss and falls in love with her.
What this book deals with, very effectively, is the idea that someone losing their memories might develop a secondary or different personality and that – in time, as their memories return – the original personality may reappear. It makes for a really compelling slice of noir drama and a great introduction to Dard’s work.
The Good Son (2016) by You-Jeong Jeong (Translated by Chi-Young Kim)
Why Did I Do It?
A young man wakes up to the smell of blood and a confusing telephone call from his brother asking if everything is okay. As he explores his house he finds his mother lying dead in a pool of blood at the foot of the stairs with her throat slit.
The main character suffers from seizures and frequently does not remember things following them. Slowly his memories come back as he decides to try and cover up what he did.
While I prefer You-Jeong Jeong’s Seven Years of Darkness, this book is a better match for the theme of this list and does a really good job of portraying how disconcerting this experience is for the protagonist.
Net of Cobwebs (1946) by Elizabeth Sanxay Holding
Did I Do That?
Malcolm Drake served as a merchant seaman before his boat was torpedoed leaving him quite nervous and volatile. He is staying with his brother and their family to convalesce which includes his rather domineering Aunt Evie. During a party Aunt Evie drops dead of alcohol poisoning. Several members of the party are sure that Malcolm was responsible and one, the butler, even claims to have witnessed it.
Holding is a superb writer who explores compelling psychological situations. Several of her stories incorporate some aspect of memory or the idea that the mind is playing tricks on a character. I think Malcolm’s volatility makes him an interesting protagonist however and left me quite unsure how this story would end.
The Red Right Hand (1945) by Joel Townsley Rogers
Why Don’t I Remember?
My final selection is also one of my favorite reads on this list. The Red Right Hand is told from the perspective of a character who ought to have been a witness to a murderer fleeing. The way the road is laid out they must have passed him and yet he cannot remember seeing anything. As he delves deeper into his memory, replaying events, we may begin to doubt the trustworthiness of those memories and if there might be some other reason that he cannot recall seeing a killer pass him.
This was recently reissued by Penzler Publishing as part of their American Mystery Classics series and is one of my favorite releases of this past year. Part of the reason for that is the book is not simply an unsettling suspense or thriller story but it also plays fair with the reader.
So those are my selections on this theme. What are some of your favorite mysteries that play with the idea of memory?
11 thoughts on “Five to Try: Memory Mysteries”
Thanks for the list. 🙂 I think with respect to Christie, I’ve found ‘Five Little Pigs’ and ‘Sleeping Murder’ to be puzzles that turn or hinge quite heavily on clues recollected. I suspect plenty of modern crime novels, drawing on the postmodern genre, play with instability of memory quite alot. But I fear I don’t enjoy the modern crime novel much…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sleeping Murder is a great choice for the way it handles how we hold onto and process.memories. Great call!
Didn’t you post this list last year?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very good… 😀
“Puzzle for Fiends” by Patrick Quentin is the first one I come to think of – Peter Duluth wakes up with amnesia in a house belonging to someone he’s never seen before. As readers, we know that he doesn’t belong in this house as this is the fifth of the Duluth mysteries and we know his living situation, but poor Peter is completely lost.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That sounds interesting – and I do keep meaning to get around to reading some Quentin. Thanks so much for the recommendation!
I would second other comments recommending Puzzle for Fiends, Sleeping Murder and Five Little Pigs. All very good reads. John Franklin Bardin also plays around with concepts of memory and mental instability in his books The Last of Philip Banter and The Deadly Percheron.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ooh, I have a copy of Philip Banter! Up the TBR pile it goes. 😀
ooh and another one I have thought of, which I remember enjoying is The Royalty Affair by George Baxt.
ooh and another one I have thought of, which I remember enjoying is The Affair at Royalties by George Baxt.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for the recommendation – I will see if I can track down a copy!