Whistle Up the Devil by Derek Smith

Book Details

Originally published in 1953
This title is collected in an omnibus edition with Come to Paddington Fair and Model for Murder

The Blurb

Roger Querrin died alone in a locked and guarded room, beyond the reach of human hands. Algy Lawrence …could not explain the mystery of this “miracle” murder. And then, faced with a second crime which could not possibly have been committed, he began to wonder, at last, if somebody had conjured up an invisible demon who could blast out locks and walk through solid walls…

The Verdict

Offers an intriguing opening and some clever points in the solution but I was a little frustrated by the pacing and some of the choices made in the investigative section.

“An uncomfortable heat at the pit of your stomach? A nasty thumping at the top of your head? I call that detective fever.”

My Thoughts

You find me sitting down for the second time to write up my thoughts on Derek Smith’s Whistle Up the Devil having contrived to accidentally delete all of my scheduled posts that were supposed to go out last week. To say that was frustrating is rather an understatement than better that then my first thought which was that they had gone live and simply no one had found them interesting enough to respond to. That, of course, could still happen…

Whistle Up the Devil has been on my TBR pile for nearly as long as I’ve been doing this blog. That is not entirely unprecedented – I have a bad habit of reading half of an omnibus and leaving the rest untouched for years (for example, The Dead Shall Be Raised and Murder of a Quack by George Bellairs). It may also reflect though that while I admired the ending of Come to Paddington Fair, I found the first half of that novel pretty uninspiring.

The novel begins with Algy Lawrence being asked by Chief Inspector Castle to visit Querrin House in the countryside in his stead after he has been called away by the Yard to work on an urgent case. We learn that Castle is concerned for the safety of his friend Roger Querrin who is about to get married as he is insisting on recreating a family tradition that had led to the death of an ancestor.

Lawrence tries to decline the request but his curiosity gets the better of him and he joins the vigil, assisting the local police in providing a perimeter around the room’s entrances and windows. Inevitably however history repeats himself and Querrin is discovered dead with a knife in his back. The entrances to the room had been under constant observation making the murder seem impossible.

Okay, so plenty to discuss here but before I get into the investigative portion of the novel I do want to stress how well I think the first two chapters set up the conditions of the crime and point to some possible points of interest. One thing I particularly noted is how quickly this material is set up and the clarity of the descriptions of the space and of the various players’ positions. The impossibility is clear and it is easy to see why the conditions of the crime would appear so puzzling to those keeping guard.

I should also say that the family legend of supernatural doom and destruction is a favorite trope of mine in this sort of fiction and while this is not as outlandish as some (for example, Paul Halter’s The Lord of Misrule), I think it is sufficiently simple that you could accept both the idea of the family ceremony and also the reason why a supernatural event might be tied to it. As starting points for stories go, I think this is pretty solid.

Unfortunately, I was less pleased with the body of the investigation. Part of the issue here is connected to the book’s pacing. After getting things off to such a quick start, throwing us into a potential murder case on the day it is supposed to happen and giving us an account of the wait for something to happen, the sudden deceleration that occurs once questions begun to be asked struck me as quite jarring.

Perhaps it also didn’t help that the cast of potential suspects provided is fairly small and contained a character in the form of Uncle Russ, an older man with a predilection for young, attractive women, that I found boorish rather than charmingly roguish as I suspect I was supposed to. Meanwhile the female characters are almost entirely characterized and described in terms of their sexual appeal.

Derek Smith was clearly a huge enthusiast of the impossible crime story. There are references and call-outs galore to writers like Carr and Clayton Rawson that will no doubt be a source of delight to some. I get the appeal of those moments – I am, after all, also a huge Doctor Who fan and get the joy that comes with seeing things I love get name checked. Here however I felt it gets in the way of the story and highlights the artificiality of the detective story format and contributed to the sense that we went from a place of apprehension and suspense to something rather more self-aware. Halter, of course, is just as well read and similarly draws influence from classic works but those parallels feels more like treats for the widely-read impossible crimes enthusiast to spot and appreciate for themselves.

Things do pick up a little with the introduction of a second impossibility which offers another take on the idea of a crime being committed under the detectives’ noses. I do feel that the ultimate explanation of how and why that second murder took place struck me as a little less clever than the first but as secondary crimes go it is solid enough and I do appreciate what it ends up adding to the story overall.

While I may have felt that the middle of this novel seemed to sag, I will say that the solution is at least interesting and I enjoyed some of the developments that occur in the final few chapters. I also appreciate that while the crime may seem complex, the solution to it is quite simple and the tricks worked are pretty clever and make sense – even when the killer seems to be taking some pretty big risks. Occasionally I have complained about problems of motive with impossible crime novels but that is not the case at all here – indeed one of the aspects of the novel that impressed me most was that there was some thought given to the psychology of what was happening in the discussion of the crime at the end.

I also think Lawrence’s explanation is laid out very well. Each aspect of the solution is clearly and logically explained, making it seem all the more convincing. Is it flawless? Perhaps not. The author acknowledges one problem, admittedly more to do with plotting clarity than feasibility, in a letter included in the edition I read where they also describe how they would have made some small changes to tighten an aspect of the solution. Overall I felt quite satisfied, even if it lacked the excitement I felt as the impossibility came into view towards the end of Come to Paddington Fair.

Overall I felt that Whistle Up the Devil offered up some points of interest, even if it didn’t manage to sustain the excitement of its first few chapters. Personally I think there are some stronger titles in the Locked Room International library but it is certainly worth a look for puzzle fans, especially as the omnibus edition represents some excellent value for money.


11 thoughts on “Whistle Up the Devil by Derek Smith

  1. Glad to see you had some positive things to say about this one. I’m about a third of the way through *Come to Paddington Fair* so far as my introduction to Derek Smith, and while I think the central conceit of “multiple people fire at the same victim” is interesting, the direction they immediately took it makes me uncannily sure I’ve seen through the principle deception much earlier than I probably would have liked, which is admittedly clever but also a bit too bold to miss. It’s making me very apprehensive about tackling *Whistle Up the Devil* next, but… this is the most negative review of the book I’ve seen, and it’s still pretty favorable, so that bodes well for it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. If it’s any encouragement, I think Whistle Up the Devil is the superior of the two. But, as usually, there are some contrarians who find fault with my impeccable taste and flawless judgment.

      Liked by 1 person

    2. This is what I wrote at Goodreads:
      The novel Whistle Up The Devil involves the detective Algy Lawrence, a romantic young person in his 20’s. It is a brilliant locked room mystery. I regard it as a masterpiece. A must reading for mystery fans.
      Roger Querrin, a business man, locks himself in a supposedly haunted room on the ground floor, as part of a ritual, one month before his marriage. The door is locked from inside and the only other entrance to the room, the French windows are bolted from inside. Algy along with Roger’s brother Peter keep a watch outside the passage leading to the room, while Sergeant Hardinge keeps watch on the French windows from outside the house. At midnight, a scream is heard and when the locked door is forced open, Roger is found murdered. There is a second locked room murder later.
      Both the locked room murders have really ingenious and highly satisfying solutions. After reading the novel, the reader is advised to reread it. He will note that all the clues are there and this is definitely a fair play mystery.
      The novel is unputdownable and the suspense becomes unbearable especially towards the end.

      Like

    3. I will say that it is more than possible that I just wasn’t feeling it on the day. I back-to-backed this with another book that I did not enjoy very much and which has some similarities that may have led to those elements irritating me more than they may have done on another day.
      Very glad you are enjoying CtPF so far and hope you enjoy this one too if you give it a go.

      Like

  2. This is what I wrote at Goodreads:
    The novel Whistle Up The Devil involves the detective Algy Lawrence, a romantic young person in his 20’s. It is a brilliant locked room mystery. I regard it as a masterpiece. A must reading for mystery fans.
    Roger Querrin, a business man, locks himself in a supposedly haunted room on the ground floor, as part of a ritual, one month before his marriage. The door is locked from inside and the only other entrance to the room, the French windows are bolted from inside. Algy along with Roger’s brother Peter keep a watch outside the passage leading to the room, while Sergeant Hardinge keeps watch on the French windows from outside the house. At midnight, a scream is heard and when the locked door is forced open, Roger is found murdered. There is a second locked room murder later.
    Both the locked room murders have really ingenious and highly satisfying solutions. After reading the novel, the reader is advised to reread it. He will note that all the clues are there and this is definitely a fair play mystery.
    The novel is unputdownable and the suspense becomes unbearable especially towards the end.

    Like

  3. This is what I wrote at Goodreads:
    The novel Whistle Up The Devil involves the detective Algy Lawrence, a romantic young person in his 20’s. It is a brilliant locked room mystery. I regard it as a masterpiece. A must reading for mystery fans.
    Roger Querrin, a business man, locks himself in a supposedly haunted room on the ground floor, as part of a ritual, one month before his marriage. The door is locked from inside and the only other entrance to the room, the French windows are bolted from inside. Algy along with Roger’s brother Peter keep a watch outside the passage leading to the room, while Sergeant Hardinge keeps watch on the French windows from outside the house. At midnight, a scream is heard and when the locked door is forced open, Roger is found murdered. There is a second locked room murder later.
    Both the locked room murders have really ingenious and highly satisfying solutions. After reading the novel, the reader is advised to reread it. He will note that all the clues are there and this is definitely a fair play mystery.
    The novel is unputdownable and the suspense becomes unbearable especially towards the end.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I just checked my spam and pending and don’t see any pending messages from today. I think you should be auto-approved (this one was). Maybe WordPress is being funky? Are you able to resend it?

      Like

Leave a Reply to Santosh Iyer Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s